Approaches to Aviation Safety Management

Advantages and Drawbacks of the Predictive, Proactive and Reactive Approaches to Aviation Security Administration


Security administration in aviation shouldn't be a brand new 21st century subject. Up to now aviation security enchancment was characterised by a fly-crash-fix-fly method. We discovered fly airplanes which have the occasional unlucky crash and we'd examine the trigger(s) to stop it from taking place once more. Typically the causes could be climate associated or mechanical failures, however extra usually the primary trigger could be human error normally “the pilot”. Primarily, the prevailing philosophy was as soon as decided to be the pilot; subsequently, different pilots had been merely inspired to not make the identical errors that occurred earlier than. Security administration shouldn't be seen as merely a way to an finish or a blind adherence to business requirements, however reasonably as an organization and business broad dedication to one of the best practices and steady enchancment of all the things security associated. In an efficient security administration system, the main target is shifted from a reactive to proactive methodology of managing threat. The prevailing view of threat ought to be skilled and real looking, specializing in eliminating or sustaining optimum ranges of acceptable threat utilizing previous incidents, skilled’s views and insights. The aviation business has prior to now been snug sustaining a reactive place to security relating to occurrences as remoted accidents, and constantly taking actions solely when one thing occurs. The introduction of security administration programs is shifting the main target from enforcement centered to a extra proactive method which might set up the notion that security is just one of the best and the simplest and most worthwhile solution to do enterprise.

The Advantages and Drawbacks of the Reactive, Proactive and Predictive Approaches to Aviation Security Administration.

Security means various things to totally different individuals in relation to their circumstances. The Merriam Webster on-line dictionary defines security because the “situation of being protected from present process or inflicting loss, harm or harm” (Merriam Webster On-line Dictionary, 2017). The Worldwide Civil Aviation Authority defines security as “the state by which the chance of hurt to individuals or of property injury is lowered to, and maintained at or beneath and acceptable stage by means of a steady strategy of hazard identification and threat administration” (ICAO, 2006).

  Aviation security administration is described as a deliberate, documented and verifiable methodology of managing hazards and related dangers (Bottomley, 1999). It's a strategic course of that identifies and addresses questions of safety. It contains the essential organizational buildings, accountabilities, insurance policies and procedures. (ICAO, 2009). ICAO has required its member states to develop and implement SMS packages to enhance security and the FAA is encouraging aviation service suppliers to develop an SMS. After all, the overarching aim is to enhance security whereas the consultants of ICAO consider that deployment of an SMS is one of the best technique of attaining that aim. The transformation of the aviation business from what it was to what it's at this current time is on account of steady funding in aviation security. These efforts made by the aviation neighborhood as security have been the very best precedence for the aviation business over the previous 100 years. Developments in expertise, coaching and threat administration have resulted in commendable enhancements.

The Aviation Security Administration idea represents the transition from a reactive tradition to a proactive tradition. Globally, the accident charge won't ever be zero as a result of human error will all the time be a part of practically each operational exercise. Nevertheless, the accident charge might be lowered by implementing proactive and predictive strategies into the organizations administration system. The protection administration idea exhibits a development from a reactive tradition pushed by investigating the newest smoking gap to a proactive surroundings of figuring out and resolving operational hazards related to vital modifications within the operation earlier than they're applied.

Approaches to Aviation Security Administration

ICAO recognized three approaches to Aviation Security Administration as follows:

  •                  Reactive method
  •                  Proactive method
  •                  Predictive method

The Reactive Strategy

The time period ‘Reactive’ means being aware of one thing. The reactive method entails motion after an accident has taken place to both decrease its results or to reap the benefits of the occasion.  It entails responding to accidents as they happen. This was how the early aviation system did threat administration as a result of they didn't have sufficient expertise and technological information. The reactive method to aviation security administration is commonly equated with the well-known “fly-crash-fix-fly” adage. There's an accident or incident and we use investigative instruments to attempt to decide what the contributory elements that triggered the issue. ICAO makes use of the time period to incorporate “incident evaluation, dedication of contributory elements and findings as to threat”. This method entails the analyses of outcomes or occasions. Incidents and accidents are clear. Correcting the deficiencies discovered utilizing customary reactive measures ought to cut back and handle errors that led to a specific incident.

This method is utilized in new SMS packages that don't have the requisite security knowledge to apply proactive or predictive security administration.

Advantages of the Reactive Strategy

  • Accident investigation is a crucial reactive part of the aviation security     administration system. Accident investigation contributes to the continual enchancment of the aviation security system by offering the basis causes of accidents and incidents. Lastly, classes are realized from evaluation of occasions.
  • Info acquired from the reactive method can assist selections relating to the event of corrective actions and corresponding allocation of sources and will determine obligatory enhancements to the aviation system.
  • Most investigation train additionally uncovers hazards or threats. An efficient investigation course of contains the identification and discrimination of the speedy, underlying and root causes of an plane accident in addition to the energetic and latent errors resulting in an accident.
  • This method by means of evaluation of knowledge from quite a few accidents has aided within the identification of recurring patterns or threat elements that aren't all the time obvious when particular person accidents are investigated.
  • It gives the motivation and alternative to determine and accumulate security knowledge.

Drawbacks of the Reactive Strategy

  • In response to the NTSB, as a result of advanced nature of accident investigations, offering well timed accident studies has been difficult. Thus, it may be stated that the reactive method is time consuming.
  • This method requires a whole lot of sources for its profitable completion. It's a results of the useful resource constraints that the NTSB has developed the accident launch standards to find out which accidents to research (largely associated to the variety of fatalities or different threat elements).
  • Fashionable security idea would counsel that counting on correcting deficiencies discovered by means of incident investigation as a way to scale back error is considerably restrictive (Weigmam &Shappel 2003, Cause 2000, Wooden 1997,Kleitz 1994).
  • The NTSB has lengthy realized the necessity for much less reactive method to determine questions of safety and in aviation security administration as a result of not all aircrafts are outfitted with Cockpit Voice Recorder and Flight Information Recorders and people with these can develop into severely broken and ineffective through the course of an accident.
  • The reactive method to Aviation Security Administration could be very costly to hold out because it results in excessive incremental prices and elevated dangers.

The Proactive Strategy

Proactive means being ready even earlier than an incident takes place. It is kind of like anticipating what will occur and dealing accordingly to attenuate the results of the occasion or work to reap the benefits of the occasion. Proactive security administration entails the evaluation of present or actual time conditions. It actively appears to be like for potential security issues by means of pattern evaluation, hazard evaluation, and different strategies of scientific enquiry. It contains knowledge inputs reminiscent of close to miss occasions, voluntary security reporting, and flight knowledge monitoring that may probably determine security hazards earlier than they trigger a critical accident or incident. Though, the reactive method entails accident investigation to determine and accumulate security knowledge, security research transcend the investigation and recordation of accident circumstances to proactively pursue peripheral info and give attention to detailed consideration to the problems which will determine the efficient security mitigations or beforehand unidentified security hazards. It's extra like “accident investigation with out the accident”; the proactive methodology enforces the truth that we don't have to attend for an accident to realize improved security.

Advantages of the Predictive Strategy

There isn't a doubt that the proactive method to aviation security that results in total security is helpful for the system and might be measured in each tangible and intangible means. We must always not await accidents to study security enchancment. We will deal with the latent situations that we find out about and incur fewer accidents sooner or later. The next are the advantages of the proactive method:

  • The proactive method permits the precursors to occurrences to be recognized and remedied previous to an precise incidence thereby saving time, cash and maybe life.
  • This method to a big extent will maintain future profitability and development within the aviation business since we're capable of determine accidents earlier than they happen thereby decreasing the results which are related to a crash.
  • It helps to scale back monetary, environmental, reputational and security dangers within the aviation business because it gives security studying with out the price related to an accident.
  • The proactive methodology permits the system to maneuver from investigation findings to preventive security.
  • By designing an error tolerant system that can cut back error, the aviation group has the potential to mitigate error penalties and subsequently proactively forestall accidents.

Drawbacks of the Proactive Strategy

  • Adopting the proactive method to aviation security is a posh endeavor (Roelen, 2008).
  • This method takes ability and an intensive understanding of root causes, cause-effect evaluation, and the way out there variables work collectively to provide outcomes.
  • It requires thoughtfulness and is vulnerable to being flawed if nice care shouldn't be taken throughout evaluation.
  • It requires expensive monitoring equipments.

The Predictive Strategy

This method entails trying to foresee issues that haven't occurred within the aviation business and likewise it makes an attempt to assessment and analyze historic knowledge. This method seeks to know the present system and thru using numerous types of modeling, decide the place and when the system is more likely to fail. The predictive method to aviation administration entails gathering knowledge to be able to determine attainable adverse future outcomes or occasions by analyzing system processes and the surroundings to determine potential future hazards and initiating mitigating actions.

The predictive method is commonly confused with the proactive method. Whereas there might be an overlap between the 2, they're for probably the most half distinct. The predictive method makes an attempt to determine attainable dangers in a scenario primarily based on given circumstances, figuring out new threats in hypothetical situations and anticipating the wanted threat controls. This method relies on nominal knowledge versus accident knowledge and potentialities that haven't but occurred. It may be summarized as a luxurious of a mature security administration system utilizing strong SMS databases to handle plenty of collected security knowledge.

Advantages of the Predictive method

  • The predictive method helps in figuring out questions of safety that haven't occurred but however in all probability will occur if unaddressed points and never acted upon accordingly by updating threat management repertoire.
  • It's distinctive from different approaches to aviation security administration. It doesn't immediately use security knowledge from incidents, it's not a response to something (reminiscent of to knowledge or incidents) and can be used to confirm the effectiveness of threat controls.
  • Predictive security strategies will allow us to search out these failure factors and remove them thereby permitting us to alter the longer term.

Drawbacks of the Predictive Strategy

  • The predictive method gives simply an anticipated ‘vary’ of security efficiency and to a big extent shouldn't be totally trusted.
  • There's a nice tendency for miscalibration as what's being predicted,  might not replicate what normatively issues for a specific subject within the aviation business
  • The predictive method to aviation security administration can not anticipate the longer term with certainty. Most occasions this method solely produces predictions that come near reflecting anticipated values.
  • There's all the time a bent to over predict or beneath predict therefore making this method unreliable.
  • Prediction requires sources and these sources entail some prices that are totally on the excessive aspect.
  • It requires robust historic knowledge to assist predictive findings, robust insurance policies and procedures to research, effectively developed threat evaluation strategies, time, manpower and sources wanted to spend on predictive actions makes it onerous or inconceivable to apply.


Now we have all heard the truism that travelling by air is safer than driving. Aviation is a protected discipline as a result of way over any mode of transportation it's run by professionals utilizing numerous approaches and methodologies. Whereas accident charge has improved significantly, questions stay over the flexibility of the aviation business to take care of security enhancements sooner or later. Security Administration Programs are a product of constant evolution of aviation security. Early aviation pioneers had little security regulation, sensible expertise and engineering information to information them. At this time, cautious regulation of aviation actions, expertise and technological enhancements has contributed to vital positive aspects in security. Now, we now have the reactive method to aviation security which is used to look at previous occasions one after the other, the proactive method which has inspired combination evaluation to find out tendencies and the predictive method which feeds on extra scientific strategies all with the intention of bettering security.  The NTSB is a corporation with a proactive mission and a reactive course of, its main function is to research accidents but its mandate is to stop them.


  • Nationwide Transportation Security Board, (2009), Working Plan Fiscal Yr 2010. Washington, DC: Nationwide Transportation Security Board.
  • Cause, J.  (1990). Human error. New York: Cambridge College.
  • Cause, J.  (1997). Managing the dangers of organizational accidents. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
  • Cause, J. (2005). Security within the working theatre e half 2: human error and organisational failure. High quality & Security in Well being Care, 14, 56e61.
  • Roelen, A. (2008). Causal threat fashions of air transport: Comparability of consumer wants and mannequin capabilities. Fairfax, VA: IOS Press, Inc.
  • Stolzer A., Halford C., Goglia J., (2010). Security administration programs in aviation, UK. Ashgate.
  • Wiegmann, D.A. and Shappell, S.A. (2003). A human error method to aviation accident evaluation. Aldershot, UK. Ashgate.
  • Wooden, R. (1997). Aviation Security Packages. A administration handbook. 2nd Ed. Colorado, USA. Jeppesen.
Homework Ace Tutors
Calculate your paper price
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Why Work with Us

Top Quality and Well-Researched Papers

. Our system allows you to choose your academic level: high school, college/university or professional, and we will assign a writer who has a right qualification.

Professional and Experienced Academic Writers

We have a wide team of professional writers with experience in academic and formal business writing.

Free Unlimited Revisions

Ordering custom papers from us is customer friendly. You can do this yourself after logging into your personal account or by contacting our support through chat or via email.

Prompt Delivery and 100% Money-Back-Guarantee

We are familiar with various schools deadlines. As such, all papers are delivered on time to allow you time to review before submitting it. In case you cannot provide us with more time, a 100% refund is guaranteed.

Original & Confidential

We have mordernized our writing in accordance with current technologies. Our editors carefully review all quotations and references in the text. We also promise maximum privacy and confidentiality in all of our services.

24/7 Customer Support

Our professional support agents are available 24 - 7 days a week and committed to providing you with the best customer experience by answering all your queries.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

Total price:

How it works?

Follow these steps to get your essay paper done

Place your order

Fill all the order form sections by providing details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment model that suits you most.

Receive the final file of the done paper

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

No need to work on your paper when deadlines are closing at very late hours of the night. Sleep tight, we will cover your back. You can order any assignment.


Essay Writing Service

We work on all models of college papers within the set deadlines. We take care of all your paper needs and give a 24/7 customer care support system.


Admission Essays & Business Writing Help

An admission essay is an application essay. You can rest assurred that through our service we will write the best admission essay for you.


Editing Support

We format your document by correctly quoting the sources and creating reference lists in the formats APA, Harvard, MLA, Chicago / Turabian.


Revision Support

If you think your paper could be improved, you can request a review.. You can use this option as many times as you see fit. This is free because we want you to be completely satisfied with the service offered.