The Concept Of The Imperial Presidency

It was historian Arthur M. Schlesinger who popularised the time period ‘imperial presidency to explain the evolution of the ‘modern-day president’. Schlesinger contended that growth and abuses of the presidential workplace have been so profound by 1972, that they had thwarted the normal checks and balances of the constitutional system. He concluded the imperial presidency emerged as a result of aggregation of presidential ‘warfare powers’ that have been primarily acquired in response to America’s participation in twentieth century wars. Schlesinger linked the presidencys usurpation of international coverage to the buildup of home powers, stressing that the warfare powers and govt secrecy have been two vital units which gave rise to the misuse of energy by presidents. [4] He additionally mirrored a rising perception that the evolution of the presidency had completely remodeled the stability of energy; leading to a particularly highly effective president and a resident Congress within the decision-making area. [5] 

Till lately, many commentators extensively regarded that the Nixon administration represented the true singular embodiment of the imperial presidency. [6] Greater than three a long time later, the notions of the imperial presidency has as soon as once more resurfaced. Many students, together with Schlesinger himself, observe that the imperial presidency has been revived beneath the Bush administration, [7] and given additional vigour beneath the management of President Obama. [8] However how genuine is that this method in understanding presidential energy in decision-making immediately? How a lot utility is there in Schlesinger’s idea of an imperial presidency? Is it the case as Schlesinger suggests, the fashionable day president is uncontrolled, working past the constitutional parameters and in clear defiance of the doctrine of ‘separation of powers’.


The place to begin of this paper is recognition of Schlesinger’s imperial presidency, and that it was restored to former prominence beneath the presidency of George W. Bush. Nonetheless, this paper makes a distinction between the usurpation of energy and the abuse of energy. [9] Not like presidents who quickly assumed energy in occasions of warfare, we argue like Nixon, Bush abused energy by “claiming a close to absolution of energy to be the enduring prerogative of the presidency.” [10] Presidents resembling Lincoln, FDR, and Truman, it's argued, momentarily usurped energy anticipating Congress would maintain them to account after the wartime emergency ended. [11] It's on this distinction that we argue makes the presidency of George W. Bush an imperial presidency. By actively making an attempt to maintain a monopoly of constitutional energy, it constantly relied on powers past these vested within the govt by the Structure, and sometimes unilaterally of Congress.


“The imperial presidency of George W. Bush was constructed and enforced by Vice-President Cheney and his chief authorized advisor Addington, given authorized veneer by Deputy Assistant Legal professional Normal Yoo, endorsed by White Home Counsel and later Legal professional Normal Gonzales.” [12] 

This paper additionally makes a distinction between the imperial presidency beneath Nixon and the imperial presidency beneath Bush. A disadvantage of Schlesinger’s method is that his principle emphasises the abuse of energy by the person within the workplace, the president. Qualifying his principle, we argue that it was not an imperial presidency however an ‘imperial vice-presidency’. There's insurmountable quantity of proof suggesting Vice-President Dick Cheney was the “chief architect” [13] “behind the idea of broad-based, unreviewable, and secret presidential powers” [14] that gave additional projection to the ‘unitary govt authorized theories’. [15] These authorized theories, advocated by Cheney, [16] have been depended upon often and in numerous contexts by the Bush administration to justify their assault on particular person liberties and different intrusions of the American structure. [17] 

Nonetheless, it's clear from the opening sentence of Article II, the Structure vests the complete govt energy within the president and never the vice-president; [18] a degree illustrated by President Truman’s Oval Workplace desk plate, which learn, ‘the buck stops right here’. [19] Reflecting this level, Clinton Rossiter described the presidency as a “one man job…who…can by no means escape making the ultimate selections wherein the general public and Structure maintain him accountable.” [20] To make sense of Bush’s presidency, this paper argues that the Bush administration was a sufferer of what Janis termed ‘Groupthink’. [21] Making use of Janis’s speculation, an instance of the affect of groupthink may be discovered within the Bush administration’s resolution to pursue an invasion of Iraq. [22] Based on former Pentagon analyst Karen Kwiatwoski, there was a groupthink model of setting all through the manager hierarchy, which blindly looked for the settlement to invade Bagdad. [23] Theses neoconservative executives fashioned a ‘royal courtroom’ round Bush, and by controlling the kind and provide of knowledge they have been capable of form and affect his data, to such an extent, it could possibly be argued they have been making presidential selections on behalf of the president. Bush was merely a string-puppet, who was directed satirically by the lads whom he led. For instance, in a press convention in 2002, President Bush was requested what he was doing to seize Osama Bin Laden, a person in his conviction to be the America’s most infamous enemy. Bush responded, “, I simply don’t spend a lot time on him.” [24] This maybe explains why President Bush and Congress rushed into warfare earlier than a broad-based coalition of allies could possibly be fashioned. On this sense, Congress and the American public additionally grew to become victims of groupthink, as they too have been persuaded by extremely deceptive info. Subsequently, it was not simply an imperial vice-presidency however an ‘imperial govt presidency’, the place energy was being abused by plenty of govt people. [25] 


Schlesinger’s method in understanding the costs of a too highly effective president is helpful. Though, it’s utility of the ‘nice man perspective’ is restrictive and deceptive on the similar time when making an attempt to grasp the true nature and energy of the presidency within the decision-making course of. Regardless of working beneath related circumstances, it's debatable that the present Obama administration now not enjoys the huge quantity of govt energy, which was expanded and abused beneath the Bush administration.

The same argument may be drawn when analyzing Bush’s two-term presidency. Because the presidency entered into its ultimate bout, with the political, media and public consideration transferring to the presidential candidates, the Bush presidency grew to become considerably ‘lame duck’, [26] whose authority and affect had been curtailed extensively. Subsequently, a distinction may be made between Bush’s first and second time period. It's evident that in his first time period, the Bush administration acquired an unlimited quantity of govt authority, which allowed them to dictate American international coverage. Nonetheless, this isn't a brand new phenomenon. Wildavsky’s ‘Two Presidency’ principle means that the president wears two hats, having fun with extra freedom in international affairs. [27] Qualifying his principle, we argue that the Bush administration’s potential to behave unilaterally on this area had a ‘spill-over impact’, which quickly started to pervade and embolden the home presidency as effectively. This gave rise to Schlesinger’s ‘revolutionary presidency’; [28] the Bush administration was capable of change the dynamics of American democracy by making a ‘plebiscitary presidency’ [29] the place they have been solely accountable throughout elections (satirically strengthening his presidency as he was re-elected). Furthermore, by overriding the constitutional provisions of checks and balances the Bush administration grew to become the dominate department within the decision-making technique of the American political system. Nonetheless, it's debatable that in the direction of the tip of his second time period the Bush administration was much more restricted and constrained, particularly in relation to its home coverage ambitions with a extra assertive Congress taking part in a extra dominant function within the decision-making course of. [30] Despite the fact that the presidency constantly and arrogantly acted unilaterally from Congress, its scope to take action particularly within the home area had been closely curtailed.

We contend that the growth of the presidency to a sure diploma has been ‘reined-in’, going some approach to restoring the stability of energy between the president and Congress.


The utility of the historic and authorized method helps us make sense of the present change in dynamics of the presidency and sheds mild on how the Bush administration was capable of act unilaterally within the decision-making course of. This method means that the aggregation of presidential energy has not occurred constantly, and neither is the fashionable day presidency a supply of everlasting energy that has nullified the Structure as advised by Schlesinger. It is because presidential energy is just not an attribute however a relation. The constitutional and historic legitimacy of the presidency could put any president in a privileged place within the decision-making course of, however the magnitude of his energy is variable as a lot of it exists in relation to his affect over different people and establishments. Subsequently, we contend that presidential energy on the federal degree ‘ebbs and flows’: various from one area of political exercise to a different; from one circumstance to a different; from one presidency to a different; evolving regularly at occasions and fluctuating abruptly at different occasions.

A distinguished motive for that is due to the deliberate efforts by the Founding Fathers to ‘stagger’ the constitutional powers, put in battle into the center of the American polity. [31] The imprecise wording of the Structure instigates a pure invitation for battle between the manager and legislature, [32] wherein each establishments push the boundaries to maximise their political energy. Consequently, a ‘tug of warfare’ for affect develops between the presidency and Congress for management of the political agenda, which is extra prevalent when Congress is split, or in occasions of uncertainty.

The historic method does appear to counsel sample exists: repeated assumptions of energy within the decision-making course of are adopted every time by a refrain of criticism, which in return is adopted by stricter congressional oversight in the direction of presidency. [33] Equally, scholarly judgments are inclined to mirror this cycle, though it's debatable, that these observations are considerably exaggerated and do solely mirror that time period. For instance the notions of an imperial presidency have been embedded as a result of fierce opposition of the Nixon presidency. Likewise, the reflections of an ‘imperiled presidency’ post-Watergate have been an overstated response to the perceived restricted presidential exercise within the decision-making course of by Carter and Ford. [34] Nonetheless, it's believable primarily based on the historical past of the American polity that the choice is both govt supremacy or congressional supremacy. However, the idea of energy suggests this doesn't essentially imply that it needs to be one or the opposite. As aforementioned above, energy solely exists in relation to affect, however affect is just not a recreation of mounted sums, the place one positive factors the opposite looses within the decision-making course of. Equally, the affect of each establishments is in a relentless flux, eternally altering in several circumstances. Subsequently, it's pointless to make judgments which establishment has extra energy at any given second as proof is murky.


Based on C. Wright Mills, a president has extra scope of affect in relation to Congress in resolving points then introducing new points on the political agenda. Different commentators like James Bryce make the same distinction by arguing:

“In quiet occasions the ability of the president is just not nice; but in troublesome occasions it's in any other case, for immense duty is thrown on one who's each commander-in-chief and head of the civil govt.” [35] 

An evidence for these phenomena may be discovered within the govt’s operate to reply to unexpected circumstances extra responsively than the deliberative decision-making physique of Congress. Thomas E. Cornin contends, when such occasions happen, the presidency is within the driving seat, particularly in relation to international affairs. The presidency enjoys the prerogative in figuring out what constitutes a disaster, [36] and might exploit its privileged place to construction new developments to their accord. This isn't to say Congress lacks the constitutional authority to intervene, quite, it usually lacks the desire or braveness to take action. [37] It is because each time a president waves the disaster flag or takes a foreign-policy initiative, in most circumstances, he's prone to have the nation behind him, together with influential enterprise leaders, the media and nearly all of the general public. [38] 

This explains how the Bush administration was capable of implement their visions of an imperial presidency. The unprecedented occasions of 9/11 infused Wildavsky’s two presidencies into one, presenting the Bush administration a clean canvas whereby they have been capable of construction the emergency response. Extra importantly, 9/11 strategically positioned them on the forefront of the decision-making course of in each domains. Nonetheless, it's believable the explanation why Congress ‘rubber stamped’ Bush’s 9/11 insurance policies, is as a result of on the time Congress too favored a powerful political response and held the commander-in-chief accountable to ship such a response. On this sense, in line with sociological method of Mills, [39] the Bush administration was not exerting presidential energy, however was merely reflecting the desire of Congress and the American public. Bush was merely a surf-rider on the waves of worldwide developments. Like Kennedy within the Cuban missile disaster, [40] the Bush administration knew it was necessary to behave on their needs and was aware that an unpopular response to 9/11 would lead to a backlash politically. Subsequently, this method suggests, as a result of natures of emergencies, regardless of who occurs to be president, each incumbent is compelled to observe a plan of action that the majority Individuals and congressmen approve, purely for political opportunism and political survival. On this sense, the presidency shapes the president.

However, the utility of Barber’s psychological method suggests presidents additionally form presidencies. [41] Though presidential selections are decided by political and different constraints largely past their management, the persona of the incumbent is important in serving to form presidential selections. Presidential selections could also be influenced by the ‘local weather of expectation’ and ‘energy state of affairs’, [42] however as a result of they get pleasure from the most effective bully pulpit, presidents actively attempt to affect the general public and educate them by means of numerous means into going together with what they need. [43] Within the case of the Bush Presidency, the administration efficiently manipulated each the general public and Congress in regards to the severity of risk Iraq imposed. A basic motive why Congress was simply tricked into warfare was as a result of Congress relied closely upon the knowledge offered by the White Home to tell them in regards to the debate. Within the home area, Congress is extra of an knowledgeable and might rely on numerous avenues of knowledge to achieve a greater understanding. Nonetheless, in international affairs info is extra restricted and it's often the case Congress goes together with the experience of the manager. Because the American media usually didn't report precisely on the Center East wars, specializing in rallying behind the troops, the Bush administration was within the privileged place of teaching the general public and Congress about America’s profitable marketing campaign towards the warfare on terrorism. As there was no official oppositional chief to problem Bush, his presidency was capable of form American international coverage unilaterally, thus permitting President Bush to turn out to be an imperial president whose actions have been undisputed by Congress. It was solely till casualties began mounting up, that the general public assist began wavering. Within the absence of public consensus, Congress grew to become extra assertive in relation to Bush’s insurance policies, because it grew to become involved about its lack of involvement within the technique of the wars that was draining America out of its males and sources. Nonetheless, by then it was all too late. For the sake of nationwide status Congress was dedicated (as normal) to maintain funding the wars which had allowed the presidency to run riot. The irony right here is, though, the wars liberated the presidency from the constraints of the home setting, it projected the presidency right into a extra advanced and unstable setting with multiply constraints. As soon as Bush dedicated the troops, he discovered it extraordinarily tough to drag the troops out. This meant they grew to become a part of the environmental parameters inside which the Obama administration needed to function in. Once more, the irony right here is, quite than embolden the home presidency it has reversed the method and added extra constraints on the Obama presidency.


Does america nonetheless have an imperial presidency? The issue within the reply lies with the idea. The imperial presidency nonetheless means many issues to many individuals. The reply is additional difficult as it's onerous to tell apart between a powerful presidency and imperial presidency. Schlesinger’s idea implies that the imperial presidency exists due to the president’s prerogative in international coverage which he abuses to increase his different powers. The issue right here is, as a result of the Supreme Court docket hardly ever passes judgments in relation to presidential abuses on this area, [44] we're left with political judgments from politicians and students which might be conflicting, as there may be a couple of standards to guage presidential energy. It's like Michael Novak noticed, “the fitting worries in regards to the imperial president at dwelling; the left in regards to the imperial president overseas.” [45] That is evident for the Obama presidency. As he has carried out a unprecedented quantity of laws and continued govt secrecy, some commentators contend that he has prolonged Bush’s legacy. [46] They see his formidable financial and social insurance policies as unconstitutional. As aforementioned above, the fashionable day president is compelled for the sake of American prosperity to pursue sure sorts of financial and social insurance policies. Simply because the Obama presidency has been profitable, it doesn't imply different actors haven't haven't influenced the ultimate resolution. In a lot of the laws handed, Obama has needed to compromise, even his nationwide well being care programme.

We conclude that the seeds of an imperial presidency have at all times existed. Nonetheless, for it to flourish there needs to be a mix of males and occasions. [47] If the person within the workplace doesn't have a way for energy and depends on the formal powers of the workplace then it's possible the system of checks and balances will maintain agency. Equally, extraordinary occasions can curtail presidential energy. America lately had the diplomatic model of 9/11 with confidential cables being uncovered, withdrawing much more affect from the president in decision-making energy. [48] 

Homework Ace Tutors
Calculate your paper price
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Why Work with Us

Top Quality and Well-Researched Papers

. Our system allows you to choose your academic level: high school, college/university or professional, and we will assign a writer who has a right qualification.

Professional and Experienced Academic Writers

We have a wide team of professional writers with experience in academic and formal business writing.

Free Unlimited Revisions

Ordering custom papers from us is customer friendly. You can do this yourself after logging into your personal account or by contacting our support through chat or via email.

Prompt Delivery and 100% Money-Back-Guarantee

We are familiar with various schools deadlines. As such, all papers are delivered on time to allow you time to review before submitting it. In case you cannot provide us with more time, a 100% refund is guaranteed.

Original & Confidential

We have mordernized our writing in accordance with current technologies. Our editors carefully review all quotations and references in the text. We also promise maximum privacy and confidentiality in all of our services.

24/7 Customer Support

Our professional support agents are available 24 - 7 days a week and committed to providing you with the best customer experience by answering all your queries.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

Total price:

How it works?

Follow these steps to get your essay paper done

Place your order

Fill all the order form sections by providing details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment model that suits you most.

Receive the final file of the done paper

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

No need to work on your paper when deadlines are closing at very late hours of the night. Sleep tight, we will cover your back. You can order any assignment.


Essay Writing Service

We work on all models of college papers within the set deadlines. We take care of all your paper needs and give a 24/7 customer care support system.


Admission Essays & Business Writing Help

An admission essay is an application essay. You can rest assurred that through our service we will write the best admission essay for you.


Editing Support

We format your document by correctly quoting the sources and creating reference lists in the formats APA, Harvard, MLA, Chicago / Turabian.


Revision Support

If you think your paper could be improved, you can request a review.. You can use this option as many times as you see fit. This is free because we want you to be completely satisfied with the service offered.