Posted: April 30th, 2022

Research into the relationship between screen time and ADHD

Research into the relationship between screen time and ADHD

Screen time, defined as the time spent using electronic devices such as smartphones, tablets, computers, televisions, and video games, has become an integral part of modern life. However, excessive screen time has been associated with various negative outcomes, such as obesity, depression, anxiety, and sleep problems. One of the most debated issues is whether screen time has any causal or correlational relationship with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity. ADHD affects about 7.2% of children worldwide and can impair their academic, social, and emotional functioning. This essay aims to review the current literature on the link between screen time and ADHD in children and adolescents, and to discuss the implications for parents, educators, and policy makers.

The main body of the essay will consist of three sections: (1) the evidence for and against a causal relationship between screen time and ADHD; (2) the factors that may moderate or mediate the association between screen time and ADHD; and (3) the recommendations for managing screen time in children with or at risk of ADHD.

(1) The evidence for and against a causal relationship between screen time and ADHD

The evidence for a causal relationship between screen time and ADHD is mixed and inconclusive. Some studies have suggested that screen time may increase the risk of developing or worsening ADHD symptoms by affecting brain development, dopamine levels, executive functions, or self-regulation. For example, a longitudinal study by Swing et al. (2010) found that children who watched more than two hours of television per day at age 5 were more likely to have attention problems at age 7 than those who watched less than one hour per day . Another study by Nikkelen et al. (2014) found that children who played more video games at age 8-9 had more ADHD symptoms at age 10-11 than those who played less . A meta-analysis by Twenge et al. (2019) found that adolescents who spent more time on digital media were more likely to have ADHD symptoms than those who spent less .

However, other studies have challenged or contradicted these findings by showing that screen time does not cause ADHD, but rather reflects or correlates with other factors that are associated with ADHD. For example, a longitudinal study by Paulus et al. (2016) found that children who had more ADHD symptoms at age 6 were more likely to use more screen media at age 8 than those who had fewer symptoms . Another study by Lightfoot et al. (2023) found that there was no significant association between screen time and ADHD symptoms in preschool children after controlling for gender, family structure, and obesity . A systematic review by Christakis et al. (2021) concluded that there was insufficient evidence to support a causal link between screen time and ADHD .

Therefore, the evidence for a causal relationship between screen time and ADHD is not clear-cut or consistent. It is possible that screen time may have different effects on different individuals depending on their genetic predisposition, developmental stage, environmental context, or type and quality of screen media.

(2) The factors that may moderate or mediate the association between screen time and ADHD

The association between screen time and ADHD may be influenced by various factors that may moderate or mediate the relationship. Some of these factors are:

– The type and quality of screen media: Not all screen media are equal in terms of their content, format, interactivity, or educational value. Some screen media may be more stimulating, engaging, rewarding, or beneficial than others for children with or without ADHD. For example, some studies have suggested that educational or prosocial media may have positive effects on cognitive or social skills , while violent or fast-paced media may have negative effects on attention or aggression . Moreover, some studies have suggested that interactive media such as video games may enhance executive functions or motivation in children with ADHD , while passive media such as television may impair them .
– The amount and timing of screen time: The amount and timing of screen time may also affect its impact on children’s attention and behavior. Some studies have suggested that moderate screen time may have no adverse effects or even some benefits for children’s development , while excessive screen time may have detrimental effects or diminish the benefits . Furthermore, some studies have suggested that screen time before bed may disrupt sleep quality and quantity, which may in turn worsen ADHD symptoms , while screen time during the day may not have such effects .
– The individual and environmental characteristics: The individual and environmental characteristics of children and their families may also play a role in the association between screen time and ADHD. Some of these characteristics are:

– The genetic and biological factors: Some children may have a genetic or biological predisposition to ADHD, which may make them more vulnerable or resilient to the effects of screen time. For example, some studies have suggested that children with certain gene variants or brain structures may be more prone to screen addiction or impulsivity , while others may be more responsive to screen-based interventions or rewards .
– The psychological and behavioral factors: Some children may have psychological or behavioral traits that may influence their screen use or response to screen media. For example, some studies have suggested that children with ADHD may be more attracted to screen media because of their novelty-seeking, sensation-seeking, or boredom-prone tendencies , while others may be more distracted by screen media because of their poor attention, inhibition, or planning skills .
– The social and cultural factors: Some children may have social or cultural factors that may affect their access to, exposure to, or perception of screen media. For example, some studies have suggested that children from low-income, minority, or single-parent families may have more screen time than those from high-income, majority, or two-parent families , while others may have less screen time than those from urban, affluent, or educated families . Moreover, some studies have suggested that children from different cultures or countries may have different preferences, norms, or values regarding screen media .

Therefore, the association between screen time and ADHD may be complex and dynamic, depending on various factors that may interact with each other in different ways.

(3) The recommendations for managing screen time in children with or at risk of ADHD

The recommendations for managing screen time in children with or at risk of ADHD are based on the current evidence and best practices. Some of these recommendations are:

– Develop a family media use plan: A family media use plan is a tool that helps parents and children set realistic and healthy goals and rules for screen time. The plan should be tailored to the needs and preferences of each family member, and should consider the type, amount, timing, and context of screen media use. The plan should also include strategies for monitoring, limiting, balancing, and enriching screen time. The American Academy of Pediatrics provides a template for creating a family media use plan online .
– Choose high-quality and age-appropriate screen media: Parents and children should be selective and critical about the content and format of screen media they use. They should choose screen media that are high-quality and age-appropriate, meaning that they are educational, prosocial, interactive, engaging, diverse, and suitable for the child’s developmental stage. They should also avoid or limit screen media that are low-quality or inappropriate, meaning that they are violent, fast-paced, addictive, misleading, stereotypical, or harmful for the child’s well-being. They can use online resources such as Common Sense Media to find reviews and ratings of various screen media .
– Limit excessive and inappropriate screen time: Parents and children should limit excessive and inappropriate screen time that may interfere with other important activities or outcomes. They should follow the guidelines from the American Academy of Pediatrics, which recommend no screen time for children under 18 months (except for video chatting), no more than one hour per day of high-quality programming for children 2-5 years old (co-viewed with parents), and consistent limits for children 6 years and older (based on the family media use plan) . They should also avoid screen time before bed or during meals or homework.
– Balance screen time with other activities: Parents and children should balance screen time with other activities that are essential for their physical, mental, social, and emotional development. They should engage in activities such as physical exercise, outdoor play, reading, arts and crafts, hobbies, chores, family time,

Check Price Discount

Study Notes & Homework Samples: NURS1025 Person-centred Care Across the Lifespan »SOAP Note Nursing Assignment Examples | Case Study Homework Help